Context:
- In November 2025, China’s Supreme People’s Court (SPC) circulated its Guidelines on Judicial Mediation in Technology-Related Intellectual Property Cases (“the Guidelines”) to courts nationwide as part of a broader push for alternative dispute resolution (ADR). The SPC’s examples show how judges can clarify disputed technical facts, use earlier judgments to guide royalty negotiations, and help parties agree on a license that covers past and future use and settles related litigation at home and abroad (January 27, 2026 publication of the SPC Guidelines).
- In 2021, Crystal Clear Codec, LLC (CCC) sued OPPO in the Xiamen Intermediate People’s Court (“the Xiamen court”), alleging that OPPO infringed six patents essential to the Enhanced Voice Services (EVS) speech coding standard. The Xiamen court found three of the patents essential and infringed. Both sides appealed. CCC sought an injunction and higher damages, while OPPO challenged the finding of essentiality. The five-year dispute also reached the German courts and the Munich Local Division of the UPC.
What’s new: On November 20, 2026, the SPC revealed how its judges arrived at a proposed royalty in mediation. After four hearings on whether CCC’s patents were essential to EVS and whether OPPO’s phones used the technology, the panel turned to a comparable license that CCC shared with the judges alone. The judges explained to both sides why they had selected that license and how they had calculated their proposal. OPPO could assess the figure without seeing the third-party agreement, and the judges could give the parties a basis for negotiation without making their proposal public. The parties ultimately settled on an amount close to the panel’s proposal (November 20, 2026 SPC report on the OPPO–CCC mediation).
Direct impact: At the panel’s invitation, senior executives from OPPO and CCC joined the negotiations that led to a global settlement. The deal resolved claims over past sales and gave OPPO a worldwide license covering every EVS patent family CCC had the right to license. The parties also agreed to end their infringement proceedings in China, Germany, and the UPC.
Wider ramifications: For the SPC, judicial mediation has particular appeal in disputes involving foreign parties, and that appeal extends beyond standard-essential patent (SEP) licensing. A court hearing a domestic infringement claim could invite debate over the reach of its jurisdiction if it set a worldwide royalty. In mediation, judges can propose a rate and leave the parties to decide whether to accept it, which territories to cover and which disputes to settle. From 2019 through 2025, 36.7% of the foreign-related civil appeals on the merits concluded by the SPC’s Intellectual Property Court (IP Court) ended in a mediated settlement or withdrawal following mediation, nearly twice the nationwide rate for foreign-related civil appeals (January 28, 2026 SPC mediation briefing).
China’s top court encourages patent settlements that reach beyond the case at hand
In November 2025, the SPC circulated the Guidelines to courts nationwide. The Guidelines reflect China’s broader push to encourage ADR in patent cases, as ip fray previously reported (June 16, 2026 ip fray article). From the Guidelines and the SPC’s subsequent reports on its mediation practice, we draw four lessons for parties negotiating a SEP license (February 2, 2026 IP Court account of mediation practice).
(i) Clarify which technical facts are still in dispute so the parties know where they disagree on infringement;
(ii) Give the parties a concrete basis for negotiating royalties by drawing on earlier judgments or comparable licenses, as appropriate;
(iii) Address past use and agree on terms for continued use, so the license resolves both what the implementer owes and what it will pay going forward;
(iv) Look beyond the patents before the court and identify which related disputes the parties can settle together, including parallel proceedings in China and abroad.
A year on, the CCC v. OPPO global license marks a milestone for SEP mediation at China’s top court
On November 20, 2026, a year after circulating the Guidelines, the SPC revealed how its judges had mediated a global settlement between OPPO and CCC. The account shows how the approach the court had encouraged a year earlier played out in a SEP dispute.
The panel began with the technical issues, examining over four hearings whether CCC’s patent claims were essential to the EVS standard and whether OPPO’s phones used the technology. With that technical assessment in hand, the judges turned to royalties. They based their proposal on a third-party license that CCC shared with the panel alone, explaining to both sides why they had selected it and how they had calculated their figure. The flexibility of mediation gave the parties a way to pursue settlement while respecting CCC’s confidentiality concerns: OPPO could consider the panel’s reasoning without receiving a copy of the agreement. According to the SPC, the parties settled on a sum close to the panel’s proposal.
The settlement went beyond the six Chinese patents at issue in the infringement appeals. It resolved claims over past sales and gave OPPO a worldwide license covering every EVS patent family CCC had the right to license. As part of their global settlement, the parties agreed to end their parallel proceedings in China, Germany and the UPC, with a carve-out for certain Chinese court challenges to patent validity decisions.
In its five-year dispute with OPPO, CCC won on infringement in Xiamen and sued in Munich, while its Polish affiliate sued at the UPC
- August 2021. CCC sued OPPO in the Xiamen court over six former Huawei patents it alleged were essential to EVS. The suits covered 132 handset models and sought 198 million renminbi (RMB) in damages (November 20, 2026 SPC report on the OPPO–CCC mediation).
- November–December 2021. The Xiamen court rejected OPPO’s requests to transfer all six suits to the Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court. The SPC upheld all six rulings in 2022 (SPC jurisdiction rulings, (2022) Zui Gao Fa Zhi Min Xia Zhong Nos. 179, 184, 185, 188, 189 and 190)
- October 2022. While the Xiamen cases were pending, CCC also sued OPPO in the Munich I Regional Court over former Huawei EVS patents (December 1, 2022 HMD statement).Â
- June 2023–December 2024. By June 2023, the Xiamen court had heard the infringement claims (June 15, 2023 China Intellectual Property News report). By December 2024, it had found three patents essential and infringed and awarded CCC more than RMB 10 million for past infringement, plus interest and costs (December 6, 2024 report on the Xiamen judgment). Both sides appealed. CCC sought an injunction and higher damages. OPPO disputed essentiality and whether its phones used the patented technology.
- June 2025. On June 5 2025, CCC’s Polish affiliate filed a separate infringement suit in the UPC’s Munich Local Division, asserting EP2622601 against OPPO and five other defendants (September 18, 2025 UPC order, July 13, 2025 ip fray UPC roundup).
- November 2026. On November 20 2026, the SPC reported that the parties had reached a global settlement during the Chinese appeals and had agreed to end their infringement proceedings in China, Germany and the UPC.
Counsel
The identified teams vary by proceeding.
Germany
CCC v. OPPO, Munich I Regional Court: Wildanger (ip fray firm profile) and patent attorneys from Bosch Jehle represented CCC. Vossius & Partner represented OPPO.
UPC
Crystal Clear Codec sp. z o.o. v. OPPO and others, UPC_CFI_498/2025: Wildanger’s Jasper Meyer zu Riemsloh represented CCC. Rien Broekstra of Brinkhof, acting through Vossius & Brinkhof UPC Litigators, represented Guangdong OPPO, Oleading B.V., Reflection Investment B.V. and OTECH Italy S.r.l. Vossius & Partner’s Dr. Georg Andreas Rauh represented OROPE Germany GmbH and OTECH Germany GmbH.
China
Counsel for CCC: Sitao’s Bing Wu, together with Yuanhui Lü and Kaizhen Yu of Fujian Jingyan Law Firm.
For OPPO: Huan Wang appeared for the company as its employee.
