Great style: Judge Brinkman files first UPC dissenting opinion, but everyone respects each other and contributes to debate

Court and counsel

Panel majority: Presiding Judge (and here, judge-rapporteur) Dr. Matthias Zigann, Judge Tobias Pichlmaier, and Technically Qualified Judge Graham Ashley.

Dissenting judge: Judge Edger Brinkman (The Hague, Netherlands).

Counsel for claimant Heraeus: CBH’s Paul Szynka.

Counsel for defendant Vibrantz: Jones Day’s Dr. Christian Paul.