Context:
- At present, Disney is facing more video patent infringement lawsuits than any other company (November 1, 2026 ip fray article).
- Through the Motion Picture Association (MPA), other organizations, and directly, Disney and other streamers are engaging in advocacy alleging “abuse” by video patent holders (November 3, 2026 ip fray article).
What’s new:
- Various media reports note that Disney’s streaming operating income more than doubled to $824 million last quarter (up from $402 million a year earlier), but the company will now hide this closely watched metric from future reports by including its streaming profits in a broader Entertainment segment.
- ip fray has had off-the-record conversations with video technology stakeholders who sharply disagree with the MPA’s open letter on video patent royalty levels.
Likely motivation behind Disney’s revenue aggregation
It is counterintuitive for a company to hide revenues from a fast-growing segment by making those numbers part of a broader category, especially when the relevant business model is viewed favorably by investors. In this case, the reason may have to do with Disney’s video patent licensing disputes:
- Video patent holders can and will hold, and presumably have already held, Disney’s own statements on the profitability and growth of its streaing business against the company’s arguments that reasonable and non-discriminatory royalties should be much lower than what video patent holders (and pools) are asking for. Patent holders argue that it is their wizardry that technologically enables those services (besides content, obviously).
- This applies not only to litigation but also to public policy debates.
When you have a fast-growing business segment that investors love, you have no incentive to downplay its profitability in investor communications. But once you get into royalty negotiations, you have the opposite motivation. You want to assign all sorts of general corporate expenses to that segment and play other accounting games. You can’t have it both ways if the public version contradicts the confidential one.
Patentees dispute streamers’ “bait-and-switch” accusation
One term in the November 3, 2026 open letter by various streaming services associations to government officials that patentees reject is “bait-and-switch patent ‘holdup’”.
Streamers essentially argue that because video patent licensing was focused on hardware and software for many years, they should not have to pay royalties now. But multimedia innovators say that there is no hard evidence on the table that any belief of getting away without paying royalties was rational. No patent holder or pool ever said that streamers could use the relevant technologies for free, much less did those who are now monetizing their video patents make any royalty-free licensing pledge concerning the technologies at issue. If anything, they promised fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) licensing terms with respect to specific use cases.
Multimedia devices have been a major market segment for decades. By contrast, it took some time before video streaming reached a critical mass in order to make licensing and (where necessary) enforcement commercially viable.
Streamers also use the term “lock-in” in this context. But there are two reasons for which the argument is harder to make than, e.g., in connection with telecommunications standards where entire networks are built around standards:
- There are alternative standards, and streamers are indeed using them.
Netflix mentioned in 2025 that 30% of their library is encoded using the non-standardized technology of AV1 (December 1, 2025 post by the Netflix Technology Blog). YouTube has, for quite some time, extensively used VP9 for higher resolution videos. - Streamers compare video standards to USB-C or WiFi, but those are device-level interoperability standards. Streamers are already showing their resilience by working around injunctions through the use of different standards or by deactivating features. And while it would be a major logistical effort to change all WiFi devices in the world in order to make them rely on a new standard, streamers can quickly and easily convert their content into a new format. And they sit at the source: they decide in what format(s) they stream their content.
Arguably, customers are more locked into streaming content than streamers are into any particular video standard.
The practical issue is just that even competing standards often use certain techniques that were already patented by those contributing to another standard. But that is an innovation issue, not a lock-in.
Video patent holders defend Munich I Regional Court’s 7th Civil Chamber’s guidelines
Arguably, no guidelines by a patent court have ever draw even half as much debate as the Munich I Regional Court’s 7th Chamber’s latest FRAND guidelines (August 17, 2026 ip fray article). We see comments all over LinkedIn. The streamers’ open letter alludes to them, referring to “[a] prominent Europan court” that allegedly had no evidence for the royalty rates it described as likely FRAND.
The aggregate royalty burden (ARB) that the streamers complain about it “16% of 1/43 of annual subscription revenues (increased to 25% for premium services)”. But all in all, that means 5.3% for regular subscriptions and 7.8% for premium offerings. Premium subscriptions are more expensive because the same content is made available in higher resolutions or with other audiovisual benefits.
The streamers said in their open letter that “well over $5 billion would be drained out of the entertainment sector, either in the form of lost opportunities for creators to make new films and shows or fewer resources devoted to inventing innovative viewing features” under those FRAND guidelines.
The innovators we talked to point out that an ARB is nothing more than a benchmark used in cross-checks, but the amount that actually ends up getting paid is less. There are patent holders who don’t monetize through licensing, such as because they are implementers themselves.
Applying an ARB percentage to industry-wide revenues leads to seemingly large numbers. But different streamers use different video standards.
Patent holders dispute that a dollar spent on patent royalties is automatically a dollar less spent on content production or streamers’ own innovation. Streaming services rely on many inputs that power them. Video compression is an important one of them. Therefore, innovators prefer to portray their royalties as part of the cost of delivering content. Delivery does not cannibalize production.
Without compression, video would take hours, day or weeks to download instead of real-time delivery. Or we could all go back to mailing out DVDs (which is how Netflix once started).
Patentees argue that without their technologies, the market for such streaming services would not exist. And now that this market has reached a certain size, they want their fair share.
