Federal Circuit rejects Netlist’s prior art inoperability defense, affirms patent invalidation

Context: Netlist, Inc. owns two U.S. patents, Nos. 11093417 and 9858215, (“Memory module with data buffering”), covering computer memory modules that use buffering circuitry to manage data transfers between memory devices and a computer’s memory controller. Samsung and Micron challenged the patents in inter partes review (IPR) proceedings before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB), relying on prior art concerning memory-module architecture and industry-standard DDR2 memory technology.

What’s new: On November 13, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued a precedential decision affirming the PTAB’s finding that all claims of Netlist’s two memory-buffering patents were unpatentable for obviousness. The court held that a proposed combination of prior art references may support an obviousness finding even if it renders the primary reference inoperable for its original purpose, provided the combination remains operable for the purposes of the claimed invention and substantial evidence supports a motivation to combine.

Direct impact: Netlist lost its appeal, leaving all claims of its two memory-buffering patents unpatentable following the PTAB’s obviousness determinations. 

Wider ramifications: The precedential ruling clarified the limits of inoperability arguments in obviousness challenges under 35 U.S.C. § 103. Patent owners cannot defeat a proposed prior art combination merely by showing that it compromises the original reference’s intended purpose. However, the loss of functionality may remain relevant where it undermines the asserted motivation to combine or defeats an objective shared with the claimed invention.

To Read The Full Story

Continue reading your article with a Membership

Court and counsel

Panel: Circuit Judges Timothy B. Dyk, Richard Linn, and Raymond T. Chen.

Netlist is represented by Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox’s William Milliken, Richard M. Bemben, and Richard Crudo.