Context: After Hisense filed a 185-page defense in InterDigital’s Brazilian case over video coding patents, the court ordered it to submit a summary (July 16, 2026 ip fray article). Earlier this week, a different Rio business court granted InterDigital a preliminary injunction (PI) against TCL over the same two patents (October 27, 2026 ip fray article). InterDigital’s stock rose by more than 4% after it reported strong third-quarter results on October 29, 2026 (October 29, 2026, InterDigital, press release).
What’s new: Judge Simone Gastesi Chevrand of the 7th Business Court of the Capital District of Rio de Janeiro has granted InterDigital a PI against Hisense in an order signed on October 27. Within five days, Hisense must stop implementing the optional H.265/High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) format in its devices marketed in Brazil, or pay a daily fine of R$100,000 (about $19,000).
Direct impact: Hisense now has to deal with a possible supply problem for its TVs in Brazil on a very short clock. The judge found that its Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory (FRAND) and invalidity defenses did not hold up at this stage, mainly because Hisense never made a serious counter-offer in negotiations that she said had nearly reached a decade. Hisense’s request for interim relief in its counterclaim was rejected as well, and the judge said a ruling on the merits is approaching. Combined with the TCL injunction, the pressure on Hisense to take a license is considerable.
Wider ramifications: InterDigital has now obtained PIs against two major TV makers in Rio within days of each other, over the same two patents and with the same court-appointed expert report doing much of the work. For other implementers in Brazil, the message is that a FRAND defense without a concrete counter-offer is unlikely to stop an injunction, and that the court expects both sides to follow the Huawei v. ZTE sequence of conduct instead of asking judges to set royalty rates. The judge also made clear that related lawsuits before other Brazilian courts will not pull a case away from the court that received it.
Here is a copy of the decision, signed by Judge Chevrand on October 27, 2026 (in Portuguese):
[Order granting preliminary injunction, InterDigital v. Hisense and Multilaser (case no. 3016671-34.2026.8.19.0001/RJ)]
Criticism of Hisense’s defense
The judge was blunt about how the case had been handled. She wrote that the early expert schedule collapsed because “[t]he numerous petitions from the parties ended up derailing the process and causing it to spiral out of control”. Hisense was the main target of her criticism, though.
She called the original 185-page defense a “trial by avalanche”. Ordering a summary did not help either: “In truth, ordering the defendant to submit a summary of her defense was of no use”. The summarized version, she wrote, “far from achieving that purpose, borders on an insult to the Court”.
InterDigital had argued that Hisense abused its right of defense by dropping entire claims from the summary. The judge called that point valid, but said she would still analyze the omitted arguments to avoid any later claim of nullity. She has not yet imposed a fine for dilatory conduct, but warned Hisense to stop. A Brazilian court previously sanctioned Hisense for litigation misconduct in a different case (February 6, 2026 ip fray article).
On substance, she described Hisense’s position as incoherent. Hisense argued that the patents are not essential and not infringed, yet it admitted using the Advanced Video Coding (AVC) and HEVC standards in its TVs and asked the court to set a FRAND royalty for them.
Praise for InterDigital’s reply
The judge contrasted this with InterDigital’s rebuttal filing. She noted that the preliminary issues were presented “in an organized manner and with the technique that was expected from the parties’ lawyers, solely in the reply”.
Procedural objections rejected
Hisense had asked the court to give up jurisdiction in favor of two other Brazilian cases involving the same patents. One is Amazon’s declaratory action in São Paulo, filed on September 5, 2025 (Amazon and InterDigital agreed to resolve their global dispute through arbitration). The other is InterDigital’s case against TCL, which was filed nine minutes before the Hisense case. Judge Chevrand rejected both arguments, reasoning that patent infringement is personal and must be assessed separately for each infringer. She also declined to coordinate with the other courts, since that kind of cooperation requires collaboration from the parties, which she did not see from Hisense.
She also denied Hisense’s request to involve Brazil’s Administrative Council for Economic Defense (CADE), to which Hisense had turned earlier (August 4, 2026 ip fray article). Quoting a December 11, 2025 decision by Judge Victor Agustin Jaccoud Diz Torres in an identical case, she called this a private dispute between well-represented companies with no public relevance that would justify a federal agency’s involvement.
Hisense’s counterclaim survived, though not on its merits. The judge said it may be technically flawed, but allowed it to continue until judgment, and she expressly left the other issues Hisense raised for the final ruling.
Borrowed expert report
The court had granted early expert evidence in this case, but it never materialized. Hisense argued that this was InterDigital’s fault, because it had not paid the expert’s fees. The judge instead admitted the expert report from the TCL case as borrowed evidence. She noted that it was prepared by the same expert originally appointed in the Hisense case, and that it assessed the validity of independent claim 10 of PI 0305518-3 and independent claim 1 of PI 0318819-1, as well as their essentiality to AVC and HEVC.
She stressed that evidence cannot be used without adversarial proceedings, so Hisense will get to respond to the report. Its request to expand the expert work was denied, which also makes its request to reverse the burden of proof moot. InterDigital must produce at least five license agreements covering these patents within five days, under confidentiality and without identifying the counterparties. After Hisense responds, the case file goes back to the judge for sentencing.
Basis for the injunction
Judge Chevrand relied on Articles 300 and 311, I of Brazil’s Code of Civil Procedure, which allow relief based on urgency and on evidence. She said urgency is not required under Article 311, I, but found it present anyway. In her words, “The situation cannot continue”.
Ownership of the patents was undisputed, and essentiality was supported by notarial deeds filed with the complaint and confirmed by the expert. The injunction covers Hisense’s RGB Mini-LED, Mini-LED, UHD, QLED, and Smart TV67 lines, as examples.
‘Pocket FRAND’ and Huawei v. ZTE
The judge wrote that Hisense has used the patented technology since about 2018 without paying for it, while negotiations with InterDigital would “very soon reach a decade”. A FRAND allegation without a serious counter-offer, she said, can be termed “pocket FRAND”. Her view was that it “is an allegation that leads nowhere, but rather reflects a delaying tactic, bringing utter disrepute to the Judiciary itself”.
She cited the Court of Justice of the European Union’s Huawei v. ZTE decision (C-170/13, July 16, 2015) for the reciprocal duties of patent holders and implementers. In her reading, InterDigital made specific written offers by email, while Hisense never presented a FRAND counter-proposal within a reasonable time.
She also rejected Hisense’s request that the court set a rate. In her words, “it is not up to the Court to define royalty values”. Hisense had asked for interim payments capped at the per-unit rates InterDigital offered in negotiations, $0.10 for AVC and $0.20 for HEVC.
Court and counsel
Court: Judge Simone Gastesi Chevrand, 7th Business Court of the Capital District of Rio de Janeiro.
InterDigital is being represented by Licks Attorneys (ip fray firm profile with numerous SEP achievements): Rodolfo Barreto, Bruno Falque, Amanda Terra, Élcio de Lacerda, and Catarina Baddini.
